# Scenario review memo (sample · redacted)

**Classification:** Educational / conceptual planning only  
**Not for:** flight certification · clinical SaMD · NASA ops · VA systems work  
**Tool context:** HeliosDose planning surrogate · hand off absolute fidelity to OLTARIS / ARRBOD

---

**To:** [Client / curriculum lead — redacted]  
**From:** Aryavarta Kumar · Scientific & Modeling Advisory (HeliosDose)  
**Affiliation note:** VA Northeast Ohio Medical Center (presenter frame; this engagement is independent educational advisory)  
**Date:** [YYYY-MM-DD]  
**Subject:** Framing review — [Mission / classroom SPE scenario title]

## 1. Ask (as understood)

You asked for a short review of how the scenario frames shielding trade-offs, organ-dose reading, and uncertainty — not a certified dose calculation.

## 2. Framing that works

- Separating **GCR (chronic)** from **SPE (acute)** as distinct teaching drivers.
- Comparing **Al vs HDPE at equal areal density** for SPE-proton intuition.
- Organ-resolved literacy (marrow / lens / skin / CNS) instead of a single headline number alone.
- Explicit **model-limits** language before any share-out or worksheet answer key.

## 3. Gaps / risks in the current write-up

- [ ] Absolute dose / ELR figures are presented without a surrogate caveat.
- [ ] “Effective dose” language may be read as full ICRP E rather than a partial planning KPI.
- [ ] Historical SPE labels risk being read as archive playback rather than scaled reconstructions.
- [ ] No clear handoff sentence to agency-grade transport / risk codes.

*(Checks above are illustrative; a real review would mark only what applies.)*

## 4. Recommended handoff language (paste-ready)

> HeliosDose is an **educational planning surrogate** (analytical attenuation + soft build-up). Numbers support classroom and conceptual trade-off discussion. For absolute fidelity, engineering design, or flight work, re-run the scenario in **OLTARIS**, **ARRBOD**, or peer institutional transport / risk codes and cite those outputs — not HeliosDose alone.

## 5. Suggested next teaching step

Open the August 1972 demo, walk organ table + Model limits, then require one written handoff sentence (OLTARIS / ARRBOD / `/references`) before any “design recommendation” language.

Demo: https://heliosdose.vercel.app/?mat=Al&x=8&days=3&env=DeepSpace&age=40&sex=male&spe=hist-aug1972

## 6. Boundaries of this memo

This memo does **not** certify shielding, approve crew medical decisions, deliver SaMD, or constitute NASA / VA operational support. Indicative advisory only; not a binding quote or statement of work.

---

*Sample template for HeliosDose Scientific & Modeling Advisory. Replace bracketed fields; keep limits language intact.*
